You are on a roof, under a sink, or driving between jobs when the phone rings. Every small trades shop eventually hits the point where somebody has to answer it, and the choice comes down to hiring a person for part of the week or putting software on the line. Here is how the two compare on real monthly cost, and where the cheaper option quietly costs you more.
The short answer
On monthly cost alone, a flat subscription is hard for an hourly wage bill to beat once you are covering more than a few hours a week. But a person does work software cannot: walk-ins, chasing suppliers, invoicing, and judgment on the odd call that fits no rule you wrote. If the job is answering, qualifying and booking calls, an AI front desk is the cheaper way to get it done. If you need hands in the office and the phone is only one part of that role, hire the person.
Write down what the job is before you price it
Most owners put a monthly subscription next to an hourly wage and stop there. That comparison is wrong, because the two are not doing the same work.
Sit down with a pen and list what you want off your plate:
- Answer every call during working hours
- Answer the ones that come in at 7pm and on Saturday morning
- Ask enough questions to tell a burst pipe from a price shopper
- Put the real jobs in your calendar
- Text back the callers who got voicemail
- Follow up on the quotes you sent last week
- Open the mail, send invoices, order parts, deal with the person at the counter
Draw a line under the phone items. Everything above that line can be done by software. Everything below it needs a person with hands and a key to the shop. If your list has more below the line than above it, you are hiring, and the only question left is whether the phone work rides along with it. If it is mostly above the line, keep reading. What an AI front desk actually is covers the ground rules if this is new to you.
Is an AI receptionist cheaper than hiring someone part time?
Work it out with your own numbers rather than anybody's marketing.
For the person, take the hourly rate you would actually have to offer, not the lowest legal one, multiply it by the hours a week you need covered, multiply by 52, then divide by 12. That is the monthly wage bill. Now add what sits on top of it. An employee is not only an hourly rate. Payroll remittances, time off entitlements and other employer obligations are set by federal and provincial rules. They are not optional, and they apply whether or not you budgeted for them. Ask your bookkeeper or accountant for your real loaded cost per hour before you commit to anything.
For the software, it is a flat subscription. Ours is $297 a month with no contract, and the website, the AI front desk, missed-call text-back and the review engine are all inside that one number. The pricing page lays out what is included, and how much an AI receptionist costs goes through the way these things usually get billed.
An illustration, not a quote
The receptionist column below uses round made-up figures so you can see the shape of the arithmetic. Put your own rate and your own hours in before you draw any conclusion from it.
| What you are paying for | Part time receptionist (illustration) | AI front desk |
|---|---|---|
| Base monthly cost | 20 hours a week at $20 an hour, about $1,733 | $297 flat |
| Costs on top of that | Payroll remittances and time off entitlements, ask your bookkeeper | No payroll costs on top |
| Hours the phone is covered | Only the hours you pay for | Every hour, including nights and weekends |
| Second caller while the first is talking | Goes to voicemail | Answered |
| Sick days, holidays, vacation | Phone comes back to you | No gap |
| Time to get it running | Posting, interviewing, training, weeks | An afternoon or two writing the rules |
| Invoicing, mail, parts, counter | Yes | No |
| Judgment on a call nobody planned for | Yes | Only inside the rules you wrote |
The last two rows are what decide this for most shops, not the first one.
What the software genuinely does not do
We sell the software, so weigh the sales pitch in the rest of this piece accordingly. This part is the straight version.
An AI front desk does not notice that the caller sounds like your best customer's wife and handle her differently. It does not read the room. It does not walk a part out to somebody's van. It will not catch that a caller has described the problem wrong, the way a person who has booked thousands of these calls would. It answers well inside the rules you give it and it does nothing outside them, which is a strength on a Tuesday and a limitation on the strange call that comes in once a month.
That limitation is manageable if you write the rules properly. Deciding which jobs it should turn down and what it should do at 2am are the two places that work pays off most.
What the person genuinely does not do
A part time receptionist covers the hours you pay for. The call that lands at 6:40pm, the one at 9pm on a Sunday, and everything that comes in on the Monday they are off sick still go to voicemail, and the jobs you lose in those gaps are the ones you never hear about. What missed calls cost a Halifax trades shop is worth ten minutes before you decide those hours do not matter.
A person also takes one call at a time. When the wind comes up and two customers ring at once, the second one gets voicemail and then rings the next name on their list.
The cheaper option we are not supposed to mention
If your phone rings a handful of times a day and you catch most of them yourself, you may not need either one yet. A tidy voicemail greeting plus an automatic text to anyone you miss closes the most obvious gap, and simple phone tools can do that much on their own. Missed-call text-back explains how it works. Start there, and if the phone keeps outgrowing you, come back to this decision in six months.
There is a third path too, which is a live answering service staffed by people who are not yours. AI receptionist versus a traditional answering service walks through that trade.
How to decide this week
- Write the two lists, above and below the line.
- Price the person properly, using your loaded hourly cost rather than the wage.
- Count how many of last month's calls came in outside the hours you would be paying somebody to work.
- Pick the option that covers the list you actually wrote, not the one that is easiest to buy.
If you want to hear the software end of it before you spend a dollar, the AI front desk page has the detail.
Questions, answered
Is $297 a month really the whole price?
Yes. $297 a month CAD covers the website, the AI front desk, missed-call text-back and the review engine, with no contract. There is a tier above it for marketing and automations, which is a separate conversation and only worth having once the phone is handled.
Can I have both a receptionist and an AI front desk?
Yes, and a fair number of shops end up there. The usual split is that the person handles the hours they are in the office plus everything off the phone, and the software covers evenings, weekends, lunch hours and the second caller when both lines are going.
Will customers know they are talking to software?
Some will, some will not, and you are better off telling it to say what it is when somebody asks. The part you control is that the call gets answered and the job gets into the book instead of going to voicemail.
What happens if it cannot handle a call?
You decide that in advance. It can take a message, text you straight away, or transfer to your mobile. The rules are yours to write, and you can change them after the first week once you see what is actually coming in.
How hard is it to switch if I hire someone later?
There is no contract to unwind, so you can stop any month. Most of the thinking you did writing the call rules carries over as well, because a new hire needs the same instructions on paper anyway.
Still not sure which side of the line you are on? Book a 15 minute call. We ring the front desk live while you listen, so you hear it handle a customer and put the job in the calendar, and then you get a straight price. $297 a month, no contract.
Related Posts

One Number or Two? Whether to Port Your Business Number to an AI Front Desk
Your business number is on your van, your invoices and in every past customer's phone. Here is how to decide whether to move it to an AI front desk, forward it, or start fresh with a second line.

After-Hours Call Handling for Trades: What Your Front Desk Should Do at 2am
A 2am burst pipe and a 2am price shopper are not the same call. Here is how to write the overnight rules for your front desk, including the safety script you should not skip.

How to Decide Which Jobs Your AI Front Desk Should Turn Down
The jobs you refuse shape your week as much as the ones you take. Here is how to decide which jobs your AI front desk should turn down, and the sentence it should say instead of yes.

